×
Hello world
Matches
Streams
21
May
23
May
24
May
24
May
25
May
26
May
Calendar
Configure
Load more content

FragbiteFBColumn

Opinion: The discussion on transgender people in esports is flawed

1
Following the recent flurry of news regarding transgender people in esports, I believe it’s necessary to give a different take on what I consider to be a flawed dialogue.
The recent conversation was started by the initial allegations that a transgender Counter-Strike: Global Offensive team was banned from participating in an online female-only ESL tournament. This was since confirmed as a hoax by the members of the supposed team, but that is not the point we should be focusing on.

Prior to learning that it was a hoax, Team Secret player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova gave the alleged ESL decision her support on Twitter.
Prior to learning that it was a hoax, Team Secret player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova gave the alleged ESL decision her support on Twitter.

One of the negative highlights of this ordeal were Team Secret’s professional female CS:GO player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova’s tweets about the situation. She claimed that, while she considered that people who identified as transgender shouldn’t be judged for that, she thought that allowing them (specifically, Male to Female transgender people) to participate in female-only tournaments was cheating due to physical and hormonal advantages towards “natural-born
women”.

The thing I believe everyone is having trouble with in this dialogue is conceptualizing what it means to be transgender, and at what particular moment in time, we can consider someone male or female, in order to allow them to participate in a gender exclusive tournament setting. After intense social and cultural struggles, the LGBT movement has been able to raise awareness and earn fundamental rights for transgender people. Plenty of work still needs to be done, however, when we still seem to be mixing up essential concepts and missing the main point.

Becoming transgender is a complex process and, as such, it’s difficult to pinpoint a specific stage of that change in which we can consider someone male or female. However, the problem here is that we’re looking at things from a binary lens. What everyone has to finally understand is that gender is not a black or white dichotomy. There is a whole spectrum of progress to consider during the transformation process. This leads us to another point we must consider. The very existence of gender exclusive leagues (in this case, female) is dangerous in that it represents a setback regarding gender equality across the whole spectrum. Of course, the women who participate in these leagues, and whose financial independence may very well depend on their viability, can be opposed to a potential increase in the level of competition. Nonetheless, this fear should never take precedence over upholding basic human rights.


Laverne Cox as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in the TV movie The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again from 2016.
Laverne Cox as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in the TV movie The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again from 2016.

Last year, Fox released a remake of the cult classic Rocky Horror Picture Show, with Laverne Cox, a legitimate MtF transgender, as the protagonist, who is a transvestite (that is, a cross dresser) and was originally played by Tim Curry. Having Laverne Cox sing the song 'Sweet Transvestite' is a mistake in that regard, despite her undeniable talent.

Now, in 1975, mistaking the concepts of transgender and transvestite was more or less excusable, but that isn’t the case in the days we live in. And, as it isn’t in the general case, it also shouldn’t be in esports. If the gaming community is an image of technological progress, it shouldn’t simultaneously be blemished by social measures and attitudes. It’s fine to want to have a safe space such as a female-only circuit in esports titles (although they serve a marketing purpose first and foremost) while women conquer their ground in gaming and online communities more and more, fighting for their integration and potentially increasing the competitiveness of women as a whole, as more women take up competitive gaming, which is still such a strongly male dominant environment, as opposed to more casual settings. But if they are already dealing with their own hardships in trying to find their place, we shouldn’t be making life even more complicated for transgender people, but rather recognize the effort that still has to be done through a progress in the dialogue and a better understanding of what it means to be transgender and how the narrative of them posing a threat to a gender-exclusive circuit is dangerous and should be a non-issue, to begin with.

In traditional physical sports, it is understandably an even greater challenge to deal with transgender athletes and decide whether to allow them to compete in male or female leagues because the physical differences between binary genders are noticeable enough to have an impact on performance. This becomes an even more complex issue in Female to Male cases because hormone therapy obviously requires them to take testosterone, and it blurs the line regarding when (or even if) to consider it steroid use.

Regardless, that’s a whole other conversation, and in the case of esports the potential physical differences are not that big of a deal and they won’t have a big enough impact in performance. And unlike what “vilga” seems to be claiming, aspects such as reaction time don’t differ significantly between men and women. We should also be careful when using arguments such as “women think differently”, since they are inherently sexist, and would bring us very close to suggesting that gay men should also not be allowed to compete against males because they could be reacting more emotionally to things when compared to a straight cisgender male. This is wrong because everyone is different, and whether you’re a male, female or transgender, that is not going to be the main deciding factor of whether or not you are capable of performing a mostly mental task and able to compete at the highest level in esports.

Ultimately, if we, who were born in the correctly gendered body, find it difficult to determine someone else’s gender, perhaps we shouldn’t be the ones doing it in the first place. Perhaps, on the other hand, we should simply allow people to make that choice for themselves and learn to accept them as mere humans. The rest shouldn’t really matter as much.

About the author
Leonardo "Llyev" Cruz is a Sociologist with a deep interest in Gaming Culture and Esports. His aim is to shed light on a different way to think about the cultural aspects of gaming. Find him on Twitter: @Llyev_

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

OpTic Gaming will keep both Jason "jasonR" Ruchelski and James "hazed" Cobb on its Counter-Strike: Global Offensive roster for at least another month, as the team heads into the Americas Minor.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

dignitas newest addition Jesper "TENZKI" Plougmann shuts down the A-bombsite with four USP-headshots vs. Heroic in the semi-final of ESL One Cologne 2017 - Closed Qualifier.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Orgless has become part of Riot Gaming. The team, which has previously played in tournaments like IEM Katowice and ESWC, will now be preparing for the ESU Masters in June.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The autobiography of Emil "HeatoN" Christensen is set to be published in September later this year.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-StrikeCSCounter-Strike: GO

New Operation and UMP nerf in CS:GO update

1
Tonight's patch gives us a huge update for Counter-Strike: Global Offensive, where Operation Hydra gets most of the spotlight.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The largest third-party matchmaking platform FaceIt has recently released its desktop client, and has a result been able to release statistics of how many players that have been caught cheating on the service since December last year.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

DreamHack Open Summer will see eight very exciting teams compete at the $100,000 event.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Despite undergoing a roster change on the deciding day of matches, Heroic made their way through the European qualifiers for ESL One Cologne without dropping a single map. Similarly, the Turkish Space Soldiers roster also impressed.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-StrikeCSVideoHighlights

keev Ace with AWP vs. FlipSid3 on Overpass

1
The German player Kevin "keev" Bartholomäus gets five quick frags with the AWP to secure the twelfth round for his team in the ESL One Cologne 2017 Closed Qualifiers against FlipSid3.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-Strike teams have traditionally been run by the players themselves, with the star players and the in-game leader often having the most say in personnel decisions. The routine stems from the days when a team comprised nothing but five players and perhaps a manager-figure, in charge of seeking sponsorships. As the game has evolved to the point where the top players all make six-figures in guaranteed salary and millions of dollars are paid out annually in prize money, little has changed.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Virtus.pro were unable to retain their spot in the ESL Pro League, after losing two straight series in the league's ongoing relegation tournament. This is the second time the Polish league has been eliminated from the league's main division, and perhaps this will be the first time the team actually ends up playing in ESEA Premier.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Following a poor showing on the opening day of the European closed qualifier for the PGL Kraków Major, Swedish legends Ninjas in Pyjamas found themselves eliminated after a one-sided beating from the Turkish Space Soldiers line-up.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

NiP Gaming's recent recruit William "draken" Sundin answers a couple of questions regarding his preferences in and around Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The parties have come to an agreement, letting Jacob "pyth" Mourujärvi out of his contract with NiP Gaming, meaning he's a free agent for the first time since december 2015.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Dennis "dennis" Edman with four deagle headshots vs. dignitas in an ECS Season 3 Europe match.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-StrikeCSVideoHighlights

ScreaM Ace with M4A1-s vs. FaZe on Inferno

1
The French superstar Adil "ScreaM" Benrlitom gets five quick frags with the M4A1-s in the match against FaZe in the ECS Season 3 tournament.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

After playing through the first round of the CIS Minor's closed qualifier, Russian team Hala Ares has been disqualified due to one of its players having been VAC banned in the past.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-StrikeCSChina

Savage returns to Vici Gaming

1
After a series of poor results, one of China's most legendary Counter-Strike players is returning to Vici Gaming.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

NiP, EnVyUs, and Heroic are some of the names that will be looking to qualify for the PGL Minor.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The Swedish player Fredrik "RoQuEy" Honak gets five quick kills with the P2000 versus the Swedish academy-team Rogue Academy in the PGL Minor Qualifier EU #4 matchup.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Load more content