×
Matches
Streams
09
Aug
10
Aug
15
Aug
16
Aug
Calendar
Configure
Load more content

FragbiteFBColumn

Opinion: The discussion on transgender people in esports is flawed

1
Following the recent flurry of news regarding transgender people in esports, I believe it’s necessary to give a different take on what I consider to be a flawed dialogue.
The recent conversation was started by the initial allegations that a transgender Counter-Strike: Global Offensive team was banned from participating in an online female-only ESL tournament. This was since confirmed as a hoax by the members of the supposed team, but that is not the point we should be focusing on.

Prior to learning that it was a hoax, Team Secret player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova gave the alleged ESL decision her support on Twitter.
Prior to learning that it was a hoax, Team Secret player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova gave the alleged ESL decision her support on Twitter.

One of the negative highlights of this ordeal were Team Secret’s professional female CS:GO player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova’s tweets about the situation. She claimed that, while she considered that people who identified as transgender shouldn’t be judged for that, she thought that allowing them (specifically, Male to Female transgender people) to participate in female-only tournaments was cheating due to physical and hormonal advantages towards “natural-born
women”.

The thing I believe everyone is having trouble with in this dialogue is conceptualizing what it means to be transgender, and at what particular moment in time, we can consider someone male or female, in order to allow them to participate in a gender exclusive tournament setting. After intense social and cultural struggles, the LGBT movement has been able to raise awareness and earn fundamental rights for transgender people. Plenty of work still needs to be done, however, when we still seem to be mixing up essential concepts and missing the main point.

Becoming transgender is a complex process and, as such, it’s difficult to pinpoint a specific stage of that change in which we can consider someone male or female. However, the problem here is that we’re looking at things from a binary lens. What everyone has to finally understand is that gender is not a black or white dichotomy. There is a whole spectrum of progress to consider during the transformation process. This leads us to another point we must consider. The very existence of gender exclusive leagues (in this case, female) is dangerous in that it represents a setback regarding gender equality across the whole spectrum. Of course, the women who participate in these leagues, and whose financial independence may very well depend on their viability, can be opposed to a potential increase in the level of competition. Nonetheless, this fear should never take precedence over upholding basic human rights.


Laverne Cox as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in the TV movie The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again from 2016.
Laverne Cox as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in the TV movie The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again from 2016.

Last year, Fox released a remake of the cult classic Rocky Horror Picture Show, with Laverne Cox, a legitimate MtF transgender, as the protagonist, who is a transvestite (that is, a cross dresser) and was originally played by Tim Curry. Having Laverne Cox sing the song 'Sweet Transvestite' is a mistake in that regard, despite her undeniable talent.

Now, in 1975, mistaking the concepts of transgender and transvestite was more or less excusable, but that isn’t the case in the days we live in. And, as it isn’t in the general case, it also shouldn’t be in esports. If the gaming community is an image of technological progress, it shouldn’t simultaneously be blemished by social measures and attitudes. It’s fine to want to have a safe space such as a female-only circuit in esports titles (although they serve a marketing purpose first and foremost) while women conquer their ground in gaming and online communities more and more, fighting for their integration and potentially increasing the competitiveness of women as a whole, as more women take up competitive gaming, which is still such a strongly male dominant environment, as opposed to more casual settings. But if they are already dealing with their own hardships in trying to find their place, we shouldn’t be making life even more complicated for transgender people, but rather recognize the effort that still has to be done through a progress in the dialogue and a better understanding of what it means to be transgender and how the narrative of them posing a threat to a gender-exclusive circuit is dangerous and should be a non-issue, to begin with.

In traditional physical sports, it is understandably an even greater challenge to deal with transgender athletes and decide whether to allow them to compete in male or female leagues because the physical differences between binary genders are noticeable enough to have an impact on performance. This becomes an even more complex issue in Female to Male cases because hormone therapy obviously requires them to take testosterone, and it blurs the line regarding when (or even if) to consider it steroid use.

Regardless, that’s a whole other conversation, and in the case of esports the potential physical differences are not that big of a deal and they won’t have a big enough impact in performance. And unlike what “vilga” seems to be claiming, aspects such as reaction time don’t differ significantly between men and women. We should also be careful when using arguments such as “women think differently”, since they are inherently sexist, and would bring us very close to suggesting that gay men should also not be allowed to compete against males because they could be reacting more emotionally to things when compared to a straight cisgender male. This is wrong because everyone is different, and whether you’re a male, female or transgender, that is not going to be the main deciding factor of whether or not you are capable of performing a mostly mental task and able to compete at the highest level in esports.

Ultimately, if we, who were born in the correctly gendered body, find it difficult to determine someone else’s gender, perhaps we shouldn’t be the ones doing it in the first place. Perhaps, on the other hand, we should simply allow people to make that choice for themselves and learn to accept them as mere humans. The rest shouldn’t really matter as much.

About the author
Leonardo "Llyev" Cruz is a Sociologist with a deep interest in Gaming Culture and Esports. His aim is to shed light on a different way to think about the cultural aspects of gaming. Find him on Twitter: @Llyev_

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

1
Counter Logic Gaming has joined the bandwagon of transfers by securing their new coach Steve "Ryu" Rattacasa. The acquisition of the coach is supposedly a small step in the right direction for the newly acquired organization.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

After the unfortunate leavings of both Danylo "Zeus" Teslenko and Mykhailo "kane" Blagin, Gambit has responded to the problem by revealing their most recent signing, Bektiyar "fitch" Bakhytov.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The transfer drama moves over to the American side as Cloud9 announced that Jordan "n0thing" Gilbert and Mike "shroud" Grzesiek are getting replaced. Will "RUSH" Wierzba and Tarik "tarik" Celik are the new faces that are now a part of Cloud9.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

ESEA has revealed their up-and-coming LAN final where the greatest of teams playing in their Premier Season 25 will compete for a part of the $50,000 prize pool. This time, the Global Challenge will take on the ESL Studios located in Burbank, California.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The recent unbanning from ESL events have recently struck over us. Cloud9 were the first ones to capitalize as they pulled their rabbit, Braxton "swag" Pierce, out of the hat. Pierce has now been granted a place in the Cloud9 roster under the ESL One New York Qualifiers.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Sixteen days remain until DreamHack will make its entry onto Malmö in this year's edition of DreamHack Masters Malmö. Today, DreamHack revealed the fourteen talents that will guide you through the happenings on August 30.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

A potential showmatch between NiP Gaming and VeryGames has been a hot subject lately. We contacted Adam "friberg" Friberg to get his opinion on the match, and the answer will certainly make the fans happy.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Vexed Gaming is supporting an academy team consisting of three Swedes and two Lithuanian players. According to Mark Weller, COO of Vexed, there will be a discussion regarding a potential contract extension after Legend Series #3.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

After six qualifiers, only one spot to the G:Loot Cup finals remain before the finals will kick off. The two upcoming qualifiers will mark the last qualifying opportunities as we finalize the last four teams for this week. This Thursday will be the final qualifying day as the last ticket to the G:Loot Cup finals will find its owner.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Tempo Storm have announced their return to Counter-Strike: Global Offensive by acquiring two new rosters across two different continents. Brazil and Sweden were the ones to stand together under the American organization's new return.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Hellraisers has decided to place Vladyslav "bondik" Nechyporchuk on the transfer list. The solutions for the departures of both Nechyporchuk and Martin "STYKO" Styk are some new faces that are set to play under the red banner.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

DreamHack has announced a small change of format for its next Masters-stop, DreamHack Masters Malmö. The anticipated Swedish crowd can wait to get their seats at the Masters Malmö event this year, featuring the regular GSL-format.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The sixth edition of the ESL Pro League Finals has been set to play out in Sparkassen Fyn Arena located in Odense, Denmark. The worlds elite will clash with the hopes of clinching on to the million dollar prize pool in the finals that fires off on December 8.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

It is common knowledge that in sports teams generally have a material home advantage. Some of the impacting factors are the lack of travel – which is far, far more substantial in North American sports leagues, despite involving mostly domestic travel, than in Counter-Strike – having your team’s support staff and functions available at all times, and most importantly, friendlier whistle (i.e. referees).
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Prior to this announcement, Fragbite revealed that Ladislav "GuardiaN" Kovács and Denis "seized" Kostin stepped down from Natus Vincere. As the story continues, the Ukrainian organization have now announced the addition of Danylo "Zeus" Teslenko, Mykhailo "kane" Blagin, and the revival of Kostin to complete their lineup.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-StrikeCSEurope

STYKO team up with Mousesports

1
Martin ”Styko” Styk has today been announced as another Mousesports signing. The 23-year old rising star has said that he is certainly looking forward to the opportunity given by the German organization.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The Swedish player Fredrik "FREDDyFROG" Gustafsson takes three quick frags to win his team, 30minuter, the round!
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

After the departure of Christian 'loWel' Antoran, Mousesports quickly sought to fill up the empty position as they today announced the acquisition of their last player, Miikka "suNny" Kemppi.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The shuffle-drama continues as Faze Clan announced their new superstar, Ladislav “GuardiaN” Kovács. His new home is now together with with the likes of Finn "karrigan" Andersen and Nikola 'NiKo' Kovač who are certainly looking forward to the firepower gained.
Read more

2 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 2 comments

Write a comment

At PGL Major Krakow we asked players about their plans for the now ongoing vacation. Watch the video to see what the stars like Freddy "KRiMZ" Johansson and Peter "dupreeh" Rothmann are doing during their time off.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Load more content