×
Matches
Streams
16
Sep
17
Sep
18
Sep
19
Sep
20
Sep
21
Sep
22
Sep
23
Sep
24
Sep
25
Sep
26
Sep
27
Sep
Calendar
Configure
Load more content

FragbiteFBColumn

Opinion: The discussion on transgender people in esports is flawed

1
Following the recent flurry of news regarding transgender people in esports, I believe it’s necessary to give a different take on what I consider to be a flawed dialogue.
The recent conversation was started by the initial allegations that a transgender Counter-Strike: Global Offensive team was banned from participating in an online female-only ESL tournament. This was since confirmed as a hoax by the members of the supposed team, but that is not the point we should be focusing on.

Prior to learning that it was a hoax, Team Secret player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova gave the alleged ESL decision her support on Twitter.
Prior to learning that it was a hoax, Team Secret player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova gave the alleged ESL decision her support on Twitter.

One of the negative highlights of this ordeal were Team Secret’s professional female CS:GO player Ksenia “vilga” Klyuenkova’s tweets about the situation. She claimed that, while she considered that people who identified as transgender shouldn’t be judged for that, she thought that allowing them (specifically, Male to Female transgender people) to participate in female-only tournaments was cheating due to physical and hormonal advantages towards “natural-born
women”.

The thing I believe everyone is having trouble with in this dialogue is conceptualizing what it means to be transgender, and at what particular moment in time, we can consider someone male or female, in order to allow them to participate in a gender exclusive tournament setting. After intense social and cultural struggles, the LGBT movement has been able to raise awareness and earn fundamental rights for transgender people. Plenty of work still needs to be done, however, when we still seem to be mixing up essential concepts and missing the main point.

Becoming transgender is a complex process and, as such, it’s difficult to pinpoint a specific stage of that change in which we can consider someone male or female. However, the problem here is that we’re looking at things from a binary lens. What everyone has to finally understand is that gender is not a black or white dichotomy. There is a whole spectrum of progress to consider during the transformation process. This leads us to another point we must consider. The very existence of gender exclusive leagues (in this case, female) is dangerous in that it represents a setback regarding gender equality across the whole spectrum. Of course, the women who participate in these leagues, and whose financial independence may very well depend on their viability, can be opposed to a potential increase in the level of competition. Nonetheless, this fear should never take precedence over upholding basic human rights.


Laverne Cox as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in the TV movie The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again from 2016.
Laverne Cox as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in the TV movie The Rocky Horror Picture Show: Let's Do the Time Warp Again from 2016.

Last year, Fox released a remake of the cult classic Rocky Horror Picture Show, with Laverne Cox, a legitimate MtF transgender, as the protagonist, who is a transvestite (that is, a cross dresser) and was originally played by Tim Curry. Having Laverne Cox sing the song 'Sweet Transvestite' is a mistake in that regard, despite her undeniable talent.

Now, in 1975, mistaking the concepts of transgender and transvestite was more or less excusable, but that isn’t the case in the days we live in. And, as it isn’t in the general case, it also shouldn’t be in esports. If the gaming community is an image of technological progress, it shouldn’t simultaneously be blemished by social measures and attitudes. It’s fine to want to have a safe space such as a female-only circuit in esports titles (although they serve a marketing purpose first and foremost) while women conquer their ground in gaming and online communities more and more, fighting for their integration and potentially increasing the competitiveness of women as a whole, as more women take up competitive gaming, which is still such a strongly male dominant environment, as opposed to more casual settings. But if they are already dealing with their own hardships in trying to find their place, we shouldn’t be making life even more complicated for transgender people, but rather recognize the effort that still has to be done through a progress in the dialogue and a better understanding of what it means to be transgender and how the narrative of them posing a threat to a gender-exclusive circuit is dangerous and should be a non-issue, to begin with.

In traditional physical sports, it is understandably an even greater challenge to deal with transgender athletes and decide whether to allow them to compete in male or female leagues because the physical differences between binary genders are noticeable enough to have an impact on performance. This becomes an even more complex issue in Female to Male cases because hormone therapy obviously requires them to take testosterone, and it blurs the line regarding when (or even if) to consider it steroid use.

Regardless, that’s a whole other conversation, and in the case of esports the potential physical differences are not that big of a deal and they won’t have a big enough impact in performance. And unlike what “vilga” seems to be claiming, aspects such as reaction time don’t differ significantly between men and women. We should also be careful when using arguments such as “women think differently”, since they are inherently sexist, and would bring us very close to suggesting that gay men should also not be allowed to compete against males because they could be reacting more emotionally to things when compared to a straight cisgender male. This is wrong because everyone is different, and whether you’re a male, female or transgender, that is not going to be the main deciding factor of whether or not you are capable of performing a mostly mental task and able to compete at the highest level in esports.

Ultimately, if we, who were born in the correctly gendered body, find it difficult to determine someone else’s gender, perhaps we shouldn’t be the ones doing it in the first place. Perhaps, on the other hand, we should simply allow people to make that choice for themselves and learn to accept them as mere humans. The rest shouldn’t really matter as much.

About the author
Leonardo "Llyev" Cruz is a Sociologist with a deep interest in Gaming Culture and Esports. His aim is to shed light on a different way to think about the cultural aspects of gaming. Find him on Twitter: @Llyev_

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Mikail "Maikelele" Bill is on his way to make a comeback to the professional CS:GO scene, and has been seen practicing together with a quartet of well-known players.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Immortals twins Lucas "LUCAS1" Teles and Henrique "HEN1" Teles have requested to leave the team, this was first reported by ESPN Brazil. A departure of the two would leave Immortals without the important Legends status, giving them a spot in the next CS:GO major.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Following a catastrophic debut at DreamHack Masters Malmo, where FaZe fell short against NiP and Gambit en route to a group stage elimination, NiKo’s team delivered a masterpiece of a performance at ESL One New York. In perhaps the most dominant tier-one tournament victory of all-time in Counter-Strike, FaZe finished the event with 7-0 map record, allowing only a Liquid comeback from a 4-11 deficit to win over seven rounds against them, and averaging a ridiculous 16-6 score in their championship run. Could FaZe already be the best team around?
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

1
Vito "kNg" Giuseppe is no longer a part of Immortals. The news was announced on Twitter on Tuesday evening and comes after a time of turbulence around the young Brazilian player.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Philips OneBlade CupOneBlade CupPhilips OneBlade Cup

Philips OneBlade Cup set to start with the Swedish Qualifier — register now

1
Fragbite is back to host a new tournament, this time in collaboration with Philips. Be a part of the Nordic countries biggest grass root tournament, Philips OneBlade Cup, and prove that your team is amongst the best.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Counter-StrikeCSVideoHighlights

NiKo 4K with AK-47 vs. Liquid on Inferno

1
NiKo taps away with the AK-47, taking four Liquid-players down in the ESL One New York-tournament.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

1
The German organization Alternate Attax has secured the services of Danish CS:GO player Nicolai "HUNDEN" Petersen. Petersen will replace Christian "crisby" Schmitt on the team and make his first official appearance during the upcoming ESEA Premier season.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

1
After a month long trial with Hellraisers, they have now decided to sign Turkish player Özgür "woxic" Eke on a permanent basis.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Dreamhack Open Montreal has crowned its new king after a dramatic clash between North and Immortals. The Danish contestants won the game by merely triumphing on one map as Immortals got map punished by the rules.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Mousesports have won the ESG Tour Mykonos after defeating Liquid in a five-hour long best-of-five.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The million-dollar ELEAGUE tournament has just begun its first group week where the Ukrainians based Na'Vi fell on the finish line twice. Victorious came G2 and Faze who both secured their playoff positions throughout the week.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The recent unbanning of all previous iBUYPOWER players from ESEA, ESL, and Dreamhack events have risen the opportunity for Sam "DaZeD" Marine and, among others, Braxton "swag" Pierce to bond a new alliance.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

During a Dreamhack Montreal 2017-match vs. compLexity, Tim "autimatic" Ta managed to clear the A-site all by himself using only his deagle.
Read more and watch

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

1
IEM Oakland has now completed its invite list with the last invitation going to NiP. The $300,000 tournament will feature world class teams like Faze Clan and SK in The Oracle Arena between November 16-19.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The latter edition of Epicenter certainly imprinted itself as one of the most interesting CIS-events throughout history. After an amazing show on-stage in 2016, Epic Esports Events are back once with even more firepower brought to the table.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Jordan "n0thing" Gilbert has found his way back to Counter-Strike as he will take on the analyst role for the upcoming event ESL One New York. He will accompany Duncan "Thorin" Shields who will also be present at the event.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

According to Noah Whinston, the Immortals CEO, Rafael "zakk" Fernandes will replace Vito "kNg" Giuseppe in the starting roster throughout Dreamhack Open Montreal and ELEAGUE Premier. Giuseppe has to return to Brazil and retain an athlete P1-visa.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

After the previous changes in the ESIC ruleset, ESL did not hesitate to regulate and lift the previous lifetime bans. A mere month later, DreamHack has joined the alignment and readjusted their rules ahead of upcoming tournaments.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

An exciting partnership brings new features to Fragbite, making it possible for us to provide you, the reader, with even more information on players, teams and matches.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

The first stop for the ESG tour tournament is right around the corner, featuring eight high-class teams in Mykonos, Greece, the contestants are set to compete for a €200,000 prize pool in an exotic environment at Destiny Villa.
Read more

0 comments — write comment

The comments below are written by users on Fragbite. Fragbite do not review the truthfulness of the written text and you are recommended to critically review the text. Do not assume the content of any post is truthful.
Show 0 comments

Write a comment

Load more content